BeerBorg

Do I need to stir during the fermentation process?

No, the yeast will find everything they want to eat. And when they get really active they will stir the wort.

Thank you, I have been stressing over it cause I’m on my 3rd recipe and just bottled my first one Sunday but the other 2 don’t seem to be as active. I’m thinking it will be fine it just got me wondering.

With practice you'll become more comfortable with the whole process. But all of us still have questions.

John has you covered, sometimes just starting out the directions can be confusing. Stir hard before you put the yeast in (pitch) to get good aeration for the yeast to grow and work, if want can stir a little after yeast is in but not needed, after that is just a waiting game until it's done. No matter how you brew, how it works.

the only time you might consider stirring is with a 'stuck' fermentation but that's a tale for another day ...

Thank you to all, I’m3 weeks out from cracking my first one open but I will keep you updated.

I'll add, opening the lid to stir will introduce oxygen into your (fermenting/fermented) beer which is undesirable.

Don't use visible krausen (foam) or bubbles in an airlock as proof of fermentation occurring. If you have some trub settling at the bottom of your fermenter, you're in good shape.

It's pretty rare that wort won't ferment, really.

And good for you for having patience to wait for your first beers to be ready - it's hard!

Kealia wrote: ↑Fri May 20, 2022 11:56 am I'll add, opening the lid to stir will introduce oxygen into your (fermenting/fermented) beer which is undesirable.

Don't use visible krausen (foam) or bubbles in an airlock as proof of fermentation occurring. If you have some trub settling at the bottom of your fermenter, you're in good shape.

It's pretty rare that wort won't ferment, really.

And good for you for having patience to wait for your first beers to be ready - it's hard!

Thanks it’s hard, but everything I have read on here says it’s worth the wait. I’m doing 2 week ferment with a 4 week boring time.

FYI, if you for some reason do need to "rouse" the yeast back into suspension, gently rocking your fermenter side to side is much better idea then actually taking off the lid and stirring. Adding oxygen at that point is "bad" as Kealia mentioned. Even doing what I said, you do not want any "splashing", just gentle movement.

That said, you *really* should not have to do this pretty much ever, unless you use some very specific yeast strains, none of which are available in dry yeast.

"... gently rocking your fermenter [sic] side to side is much better idea then actually taking off the lid and stirring" may be the CW; however ... on occasion when brewing a barleywine ... i've stirred to rouse the yeast without ill fx.

the expose to O2 is really no different that racking to a 2ndary ...

HerbMeowing wrote: ↑Sun May 22, 2022 9:17 pm "... gently rocking your fermenter [sic] side to side is much better idea then actually taking off the lid and stirring" may be the CW; however ... on occasion when brewing a barleywine ... i've stirred to rouse the yeast without ill fx.

the expose to O2 is really no different that racking to a 2ndary ...

Unless making sours that have to age for a 6+ months, I think racking to a 2ndary is stupid and useless 99% of the time, and not just because of the oxygen introduction.

racking to a 2ndary is not at all stupid if you're brewing a fruit beer ...

What is racking to a secondary?

racking to a 2ndary means transferring the beer from the primary fermentor to a second fermentor.

back in the day this was SOP b/c of fears about autolysis (off-flavors from decaying yeast) and the belief it produced clearer beer but it is no longer standard practice unless you're making a fruit beer or apparently when 'souring'. some would also do it when adding oak.

there's a small risk of oxidation during the transfer but not much of a concern if done 'quietly' ... i.e., no bubbles or splashing.