Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Information about hops and best uses.

Moderators: BlackDuck, Beer-lord, LouieMacGoo, philm00x, gwcr

Post Reply
User avatar
Beer-lord
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9634
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 2:48 pm
Location: Burbs of the Big Easy

Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by Beer-lord »

The last 2 weeks at the gym, I've gone from Floyd, Aerosmith and Zep to craft beer podcasts to catch up a bit. A great part of what I listened to was regarding hops ----yeah, surprising huh?
The semi-bottom line is that mash hopping just isn't worth it and FWH yields more flavor and IBU's though it's very close to the normal 60 minute hops. I heard no talk of Stone's very popular, 90 minute hop additions.
But, for those small craft brewers that had access to a lab, it was extremely obvious that the software tools we use can be waaaaayyyy off on IBU values. In many instances, the calculated IBU's were off as much as 40% in some lab results that checked for actual IBU's.
First, I want to be on the test group that gets to drink these beers and second, if I use the alpha numbers on the hop packets in Beersmith, and there's a chance I can be even 15% off, why can't they do a better job with the software to fix this? Which software is better?

Honestly, I think I can tell as many times I have a pound of hops in my beers and it might give me the same taste (bitter, flavora and aroma) as when I use only 6 oz. But, this is yet one more thing that makes this hobby so much fun and you can do the same recipe over and over and get different results.
PABs Brewing
Planning
Brew good beer and live a hoppy life
Fermenting

Drinking
Disfucted
Smelly Hops
(split batch) A Many Stringed Bow
Up Next
Men In Black
User avatar
Gymrat
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 2155
Joined: Thu Aug 08, 2013 9:49 pm

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by Gymrat »

Just to throw another monkey wrech into your thinking...there is a difference between actual bitterness and percieved bitterness. In other words, two beers can truly have the same IBU but one will be very bitter on the backside where the other will be quite smooth.
User avatar
Beer-lord
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9634
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 2:48 pm
Location: Burbs of the Big Easy

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by Beer-lord »

And don't rule out how aroma can fool you to thinking there's more there than there really is (yes, I said this!)
PABs Brewing
Planning
Brew good beer and live a hoppy life
Fermenting

Drinking
Disfucted
Smelly Hops
(split batch) A Many Stringed Bow
Up Next
Men In Black
User avatar
Gman20
Fully Fermented
Fully Fermented
Posts: 283
Joined: Wed Aug 14, 2013 2:05 am

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by Gman20 »

also the humulone and cohumulone levels can make a difference

read somewhere that the bitterness from humulone is smoother than that more harsher bitterness for cohumulone
User avatar
John Sand
Brew Guru
Brew Guru
Posts: 4310
Joined: Wed Aug 07, 2013 9:01 pm
Location: Long Island NY

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by John Sand »

Which is why it is an art.
I have a book on the shelf somewhere, subtitled: The Art, Science, and Magic of Sailboat Design.
I feel the same about brewing.
Making beer and stew for the Zombie Apocalypse.
Never mind, there it is.
User avatar
Crazy Climber
Brew Master
Brew Master
Posts: 664
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 8:29 pm
Location: South Carolina

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by Crazy Climber »

What I found very interesting was the Basic Brewing Radio podcast a while back where they ran lab tests to determine that, with only a 60-minute hop addition, there seems to be an upper limit of 50 IBU attainable.

The moral of that story seems to be: calculate the IBU contribution from your bittering charge. If it calculates to be greater than 50, then you're probably wasting some hops that would be better utilized (literally and figuratively) in a flavor or aroma addition.
Crazy Climber:
I'm not particularly crazy (IMO), and I don't rock-climb. It's just the name of a video game I used to like to play, back in the 80's.
User avatar
Beer-lord
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 9634
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 2:48 pm
Location: Burbs of the Big Easy

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by Beer-lord »

The majority of the podcasts I listened to over the last few weeks have beer Basic Brewing. I like how they are 'regular guys' and keep things simple.
PABs Brewing
Planning
Brew good beer and live a hoppy life
Fermenting

Drinking
Disfucted
Smelly Hops
(split batch) A Many Stringed Bow
Up Next
Men In Black
User avatar
mashani
mashani
mashani
Posts: 6743
Joined: Sat Aug 10, 2013 11:57 pm

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by mashani »

Software or not, we simply do not really know the AAU contribution of the hops we buy because we don't know the age and storage conditions before we got them. What is printed on the package is about what it was when it was packaged. Different varieties of hops degrade at different rates depending on temperature stored and time. Unless they have stayed frozen their entire life including during shipping and at the LHBS, it's not what it says. If I know my hops are older, I will look at hop unions stats on degradation over time for a variety and then take a SWAG at it to try to guess what I'm really going to get, but that's why I don't usually bother measuring hops below more then about 1/4th an ounce - it simply is pointless unless you have a lab and you really know what the exact AA amount in the hops is at the exact moment in time you use them - but pretty much it is NOT what the package says, unless it's really fresh. So I see no need to bother with it, I just make beer and drink it and don't stress about if I get a few more or a few less IBUs.

Another wrench, is that long term stored beers, where the AA IBUs mellow over time, the beta acids - those things we ignore more or less - start to oxidize and contribute a perceived bitterness when they do. So in some styles of beer that can keep an aged beer from getting "too sweet". This is going to happen more with noble hops or their descendants as they tend to have higher beta acid levels. Which is why it's actually best to use more of the traditional kinds of hops for certain styles of beer that will be aged long, vs. trying to shortcut with a modern really high AA/low beta hop so you can use less and save $.
User avatar
Crazy Climber
Brew Master
Brew Master
Posts: 664
Joined: Mon Aug 05, 2013 8:29 pm
Location: South Carolina

Re: Hops-Calculated vs. Actual

Post by Crazy Climber »

Nice nugget of info there, mashani, regarding beta acids and perceived bitterness. Thanks for sharing.

:idea: You should start your own podcast -- I'd subscribe!
Crazy Climber:
I'm not particularly crazy (IMO), and I don't rock-climb. It's just the name of a video game I used to like to play, back in the 80's.
Post Reply